Good Morning Birds! So in an effort to remain honest with you all (fostering trust and all that) I am going to tell you that I do not like
Jane Eyre. I do not like it as book, I do not like it for its hook. I do not like it here or there, I just do not like
Jane Eyre. It is long and drags on in many places and a lot of the decisions made by the characters make me want to punch them. But those reasons are not the number one reason why I dislike
Jane Eyre. So many girls and women read this book and devour it for it's love story. This is where I become increasingly upset. The love story in Jane Eyre is one of the most deceptive, manipulative, dysfunctional relationships I know of. It may be worse than Britney and K-Fed (don't judge). I know I am going to get lots of back lash for all of this, but let me prove my point.
Chapter 23 of the book is what most people see as the romantic climax of the book. It is the proposal scene. And what could be more romantic, or more loving, or more beautiful than a proposal? Well almost anything is better than the proposal in this book. So Rochester and Jane are out taking a walk. Jane has heard rumor that Rochester is going to get married. This makes her sad because she loves him. As they walk Rochester tells Jane how very sad it is that she must leave for he is to be married very soon. Jane grows more sad. Rochester continues to taunt Jane with the image of him marrying the beautiful Miss Ingram. Jane is very very sad by now. This continues for a while and Jane begins to sob because she doesn't want to leave Thornfield
 |
Look at me! I'm a big fat jerk face
who manipulates young girls. |
or Adele or Rochester. Finally Rochester tells Jane that it is not Miss Ingram he intends to marry. There is confusion on Jane's part, but once she knows he is telling the truth there is a lot of kissing and love being thrown around. This is not romantic! This is manipulative and mean. If Rochester really, truly loves Jane, then he shows it in a really douchey way. Now it is much easier to see how terribly heartbreaking this scene is when you read the book, but here is where the movies come in. This scene in most of the movie adaptation is manipulated by the filmmakers. They don't drag out Rochester's mocking. They add beautiful, romantic music, and they choose their shots very carefully to ensure that this scene is the most romantic moment of anyone's life. It makes me sad because everyone falls into the trap and doesn't see how truly terrible Rochester is as a person. If you don't believe he is a terrible person then let me remind you that he lies to Jane about having a crazy wife in the attic. Sooo...yeah...he's pretty terrible.
Because the book is so long it is hard to incorporate everything into one movie. But people keep trying. You don't believe me? Well go check out the complete list of Jane Eyre film adaptations
here. While I haven't watched all of them and I don't enjoy them very much because it just makes me angry there are two adaptations that are fairly decent. One is the 2006 BBC Miniseries. I like this one because it allows more of the book to be included in the film which means a more comprehensive view of Jane and her story. I also like the 2011 movie. This one is probably the most famous adaptation. It is a little strange in places and cuts things out and moves things around, but it is more interesting to watch than the older adaptations I've seen.
Well that is all for today! Leave a comment letting me know what you think about the Jane Eyre proposal scene and your favorite movie adaptation!
Keep Reading!
Buy a beautiful Jane Eyre copy
here.
Check out my new
YouTube Channel!